Its a tough choice, but my pick is Buttermilk.

Mince. (Yes, I'm boring...  ::))

Other:

Steak and Kidney

Pecan.

I love how it makes the muscles in my cheeks tense up because of the ridiculous amount of sugar! ;D

Strawberry and Rhubarb.

Though Banoffi comes a close second !

Other:

        Banana Cream Pie  :)

Banana cream pie for me, too.  What is Chess pie?

Banana cream pie for me, too.  What is Chess pie?


Its like pecan pie, minus the pecans. ;D

Apple Pie.  I love it 8)

Its like pecan pie, minus the pecans. ;D


Thanks.  Sounds nasty.  Then again, I don't like pecan pie, either.

Thanks.  Sounds nasty.  Then again, I don't like pecan pie, either.


;D ;D

I love pecan pie but just the almost pure sugar filling and no pecans?  I dunno, I think I'll pass as well.

Pecan pie is too rich for me...I can imagine that Chess is even worse.

I like lemon meringue and cherry.

Pecan pie is too rich for me...I can imagine that Chess is even worse.


I know how you feel.  When I was a kid you could give me a bowl full of pure sugar and honey and I would think its the best dessert ever.  But now I cannot eat nearly as many sweets as then.  Especially candy.

Other:

Steak and Kidney


Me too - except I don't actually eat  the kidney bits  :P :)

Other: Pork

('Specially of the Melton Mowbray variety...)

I wasn't really thinking of savory pies actually, I meant dessert pies.

Me too - except I don't actually eat  the kidney bits  :P :)
Steak Pie then?

Very very hard choice. I picked pumpkin. then key lime. then chocolate......Oooooooh strawberry rhubarb!!!

Sweet Potato followed by Key Lime Pie, Lemon Meringue, and Pumpkin!

Other:

        Banana Cream Pie  :)



Banana cream pie for me, too.  What is Chess pie?




Add me to the list.




Cat

Yes, what is Chess Pie?

Yes, what is Chess Pie?


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chess_pie

It's pretty tasty, actually!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chess_pie

It's pretty tasty, actually!
Not Cheese Pie then?

Not Cheese Pie then?


hahaha it's all in the etymology!

Lemon meringue for me.

I know how you feel.  When I was a kid you could give me a bowl full of pure sugar and honey and I would think its the best dessert ever.  But now I cannot eat nearly as many sweets as then.  Especially candy.


I've never been able to eat anything that was too sweet.  I couldn't stomach marshmallows growing up at all.  Divinity, either.  Anything too sweet makes me sick to my stomach.

I chose other: Coconut Custard

Rhubarb, Rhubarb Raisin, Strawberry Rhubarb, Rhubarb Rhubarb  :)

Banana Crea, Chocolate Silk, and (although technically a cake) Boston Cream pie.

I chose chocolate as my #1 pie, although I love some of these:

Cherry pie
Rhubard Pie
Peanut Butter Pie
Lemon Merengue
Apple Pie
Peach Pie
and almost every other fruit pie out there, I'll eat it.  ;D


Pies I could live without:
Coconut Cream Pie
Pecan Pie

Pecan pie is good depending on how it is made. My sister makes a tasty pecan pie.
Pecan Pie

Pecan pie is good depending on how it is made. My sister makes a tasty pecan pie.


I've tried so many, and still don't fancy them too much. But, at least I'm willing  ;D

Cherry pie

Nothing and I mean NOTHING tops my grandmother's homemade chocolate cream pie.  She made everything from scratch, from the pie crust to the filling to the meringue on top.

Apple pie would be my second choice

Other, Meat Pie

my favorite pie is from Bakers Square restaurant  http://www.bakerssquarerestaurants.com/images/bsq_pies/pie_photos/Caramel_Pecan_Silk.jpg

Caramel Pecan Silk Supreme
An exquisitely decadent experience. Layers of rich caramel pecan, French Silk supreme cream cheese are nestled under whipped cream drizzled with dark chocolate and caramel

I love this pie.  8)

Warm apple pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.  Mmmmm!!!!

Cherry pie
you forgot  to add - Warrant 
I love a good cherry pie myself
I like peach pie
I like banana cream

Apple pie, warmed up and topped with ice cream

My grandmother's raisin pie is damn tasty too, now that I think of it.

I have never been the type to really like pie....but I guess if I had to pick...it would be apple *but it has to be warm, with some ice cream on it*


Have any of you ever tasted Zucchini Pie? My mom makes it and actually it tastes almost like apple pie. :o

I chose pumpkin. Somethig about it makes my tastebuds tingle in delight.

I chose pumpkin. Somethig about it makes my tastebuds tingle in delight.



I like a little pumpkin pie with my whipped cream.  :D ;D ;D ;D




Cat

Sweet Potato Pie tastes like Root Beer.

I LOVE a well-made Apple Pie (cinnamon, etc.).. but Pumpkin wins.

I like a little pumpkin pie with my whipped cream.  :D ;D ;D ;D




Cat

I know I load my pie with whippe dcream too. :D

I like a little pumpkin pie with my whipped cream.  :D ;D ;D ;D




Cat


Same here. It's just not the same, ya know.

I know I load my pie with whippe dcream too. :D


I guess I'm in the minority, but I HATE whipped cream... it.. just.. doesn't go with the pie at all.

I guess I'm in the minority, but I HATE whipped cream... it.. just.. doesn't go with the pie at all.

Whippe dCream is the food of the gods. How can you not like it. :o

I chose other: Coconut Custard


That's another favorite of mine... :)

Pumpkin!!! :D ;D

Of course, it's usu. available during the fall...but I've been able to eat some any time of the year!

Pumpkin!!! :D ;D

Of course, it's usu. available during the fall...but I've been able to eat some any time of the year!




My mom makes pumpkin pie from scratch, so we can have it any time of year.  Sometimes having something like that or turkey and dressing when it's not Thanksgiving can make it seem like a treat. 

Cherry pie.

BTW, what's in Shoofly pie?

I guess I'm in the minority, but I HATE whipped cream... it.. just.. doesn't go with the pie at all.



Are you kidding?!  You can't eat pie without whipped cream!

i could totally live without pie but if i had to choose i'd go with strawberry or strawberry rhubarb :)