I put the three choices that I know people eat first. If anyone else has any recommendations, let me know. I'm always interested in new things!

I like honey on my peanut butter sandwich. It just goes really well with it, although I'll eat jam if we have any.

I like it with grape jam. 

I have eaten peanut and sliced banana sandwiches before, they're OK.

I like either jelly (favs are strawberry or apple) or fluff-which I haven't had in a long time. We used to make something that we called an "Arfer Special". Peanut butter, jelly AND Fluff on 3 pieces of bread. We called it an "Arfer Special" because my sister's old boyfriend used to make it all the time and his name was Arthur and we played around with his name.



Cat

My husband eats peanut butter & syrup sandwiches all the time.

Peanut butter and jam.

Bread and buter, spread it crunchy peanut butter, nothing else needed.

Rainbow bread, crunchy peanut butter and blackberry jam or grape jelly

bread or toast - even better

Another vote for jam... usually strawberry, but grape sounds even better!

Usually grape or strawberry jam for me, but on special occasions The Peanut Butter Company here in NY makes "The Elvis" sanwich which is PB, bananas and honey on warm toast - Yum!

My husband eats peanut butter & syrup sandwiches all the time.


haha me too!!!!

Normally, though Peanut Butter and Jelly/Jam/Marmalade hits the spot.

Peanut Butter on celery

Peanut Butter on celery
that's hecka good. I love that

With jam (1st choice), jelly, or occasionally honey.

Peanut Butter on celery



Yummy. Love that. I also love cream cheese on celery, too. And peanut butter (or honey) on apples.



Cat

I usually just make peanut butter & jelly - grape or apple jelly, bread toasted or not.

I love a peanut butter sandwich with deli meat.

I used to love PB and Marshmallow Fluff when I was a kid I fear if I tried it now I would fall into a diabetic coma or something... but I really want to try it!

I always eat PB and Strawberry Jam.  I like the uncrustables they sell...how lazy have we gotten that we gotta buy frozen PB&J sandwiches and wait for the them to thaw instead of just making a sandwich in the morning for to take for lunch.

I used to love PB and Marshmallow Fluff when I was a kid I fear if I tried it now I would fall into a diabetic coma or something... but I really want to try it!

I always eat PB and Strawberry Jam.  I like the uncrustables they sell...how lazy have we gotten that we gotta buy frozen PB&J sandwiches and wait for the them to thaw instead of just making a sandwich in the morning for to take for lunch.


Remember the Goober PB&J from Smuckers? I refused to eat any other PB&J, so my mom had to buy this stuff all the time. :D

I've eaten a lot of different PB sandwhiches in my time. (I blame it on having a full pantry and unlimited access to the Food Network.)

My old stand bys are PB with grape jelly or PB with apricot jelly.

Then I started getting adventurous:

PB and Banana--after watching an Elvis TV special.

PB with Fresh Roasted Planters peanuts for crunch.

PB with 5 Jumbo Puff Marshmallows. (My mom refused to by the Fluff)

PB with Honey Roasted Cheerios (pretty good)

PB with Nutella (A chocolate hazelnut spread) It tasted like a really big Reese's Cup.

The worst I ever made was one when I was 10:

Peanut Butter and Mint Jelly (like you put on lamb) My mother had Mint Jelly she had gotten as a gift and I just slathered it on without tasting it first. OMG! It was terrible!  8-P

^ mint jelly does sound rather nastified  8-P

I had me a peanut butter (chunky) and blackberry jam sandwich last night at about 1am before I went to bed. it was a nice nightcap  :)

PB with Nutella (A chocolate hazelnut spread) It tasted like a really big Reese's Cup.


*drools*

My mother occasionally eats peanut butter and mayonnaise sandwiches. Yeah, just the thought of it makes me gag too.  8-P

Ant

Peanut Butter on celery



Peanut butter on granny smith apples is awesome!

Peanut butter and marshmellow fluff is awesome. :)

Try smashing up some Hershey Reese's peanut butter cups and eating them on rye toast with butterscotch ice cream syrup topped with sliced banana.  Never tried this myself but it just occurred to me as something that may be adventurous in the world of food.

Peanut butter on granny smith apples is awesome!


I prefer it with Fuji apples

I voted for "Jelly/Jam" - a true classic.

But I have plug my strong second favorite, even though my husband thinks it's gross (just the idea of it; he won't try it):

Peanut Butter and mayonnaise on white bread.  Strange sounding I know, but it's actually rather tasty  ::)

BTW, hubby digs peanut butter and banana sandwiches  :-*

The worst I ever made was one when I was 10:

Peanut Butter and Mint Jelly (like you put on lamb) My mother had Mint Jelly she had gotten as a gift and I just slathered it on without tasting it first. OMG! It was terrible!  8-P



One time, Carlos was heading to the store so I asked him to get some apple jelly for my PB&J sandwiches. He comes back with apple MINT jelly.  :P  I corrected him. Now, when I say apple jelly, I specify NON-mint. I think I finally have him trained.  :D ;D ;D



Cat

Other: sliced bananas

Very good on crackers!  :)

pbj's i like peanut butter (creamy) and Strawberry, or grape...but no chunks of anything....and then i love pb and banana yummy 

I like grape jelly but I've had it with honey and when I was younger, peanut butter and brown sugar.

I like grape jelly but I've had it with honey and when I was younger, peanut butter and brown sugar.


I used to eat bread with butter and granulated sugar...mmmmm

I used to eat bread with butter and granulated sugar...mmmmm


That's even nicer toasted

I used to eat bread with butter and granulated sugar...mmmmm


That's even nicer toasted


Just add a little cinnamon to that mix - Oooh La La!  :D

I can't really stand peanut butter, but my Granddad used to make peanut butter and banana sandwiches.

Better yet I had a roommie in art school that ate, and loved peanut butter and fried pickle sandwiches. 8-P