» OLD MESSAGE ARCHIVES «
The Pop Culture Information Society...
Messageboard Archive Index, In The 00s - The Pop Culture Information Society

Welcome to the archived messages from In The 00s. This archive stretches back to 1998 in some instances, and contains a nearly complete record of all the messages posted to inthe00s.com. You will also find an archive of the messages from inthe70s.com, inthe80s.com, inthe90s.com and amiright.com before they were combined to form the inthe00s.com messageboard.

If you are looking for the active messages, please click here. Otherwise, use the links below or on the right hand side of the page to navigate the archives.

Custom Search



Subject: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: kayhepburn on 06/18/03 at 07:27 a.m.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/wtwta/2997248.stm

Check this link out!

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Bobby on 06/18/03 at 07:56 a.m.

Thanks for the link, KayHepburn.

America has a lot of optimism - I loved the whole idea of the 'American Dream'. True or false, it is a focus to aspire to.

Ok the government in itself is flawed but I really believe that, as humans, every government in the world is. I'm not a fan of the way George Bush has asserted himself but I believe that if he didn't, we may have had more disasters in the future.

This is just my opinion.  :)

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: kayhepburn on 06/18/03 at 08:00 a.m.

I agree, Bobby.
It is a shame when a country's citizens are tarnished by the reputation of their leaders..........

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Shaz on 06/18/03 at 08:05 a.m.

Quoting:The programme also revealed that News Online readers voted Homer Simpson as the Greatest American in history. End Quote



I don't know whether  to say "YES!!!!" or feel insulted?  :-/

A cartoon character that is a slovenly not overly bright albeit funny  middle aged man  is the Greatest American in History? HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHA I will go with the laugh. Two thumbs way up!

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Bobby on 06/18/03 at 08:27 a.m.


Quoting:


I don't know whether  to say "YES!!!!" or feel insulted?  :-/End Quote



Without sounding like a psychologist, I shouldn't attach too much emotional emphasis on this - It may be people's way of putting some humour into the situation.  :)

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 06/18/03 at 09:47 a.m.

Some of the comments made are cracking me up!  I liked what the person from Ethiopia said.  Some of the other ones are just clueless, like the guy who said we don't financially help other countries.  Puhleeze! ::)

Mod to add:

I give this poll the same weight I do all others (i.e. popularity, etc)---none.  Interview every single person in the world, tabulate those opinions, and I'll accept it.

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Don_Carlos on 06/18/03 at 10:09 a.m.

I think it is an interesting poll.  In my travels and residance in South America I found that most people liked us as people, but AT BEST distrusted our gov't.  That was during the cold war, 70's and 80's, so those attitudes may have changed.

And by the way Cheerleader, the % or our GNP that goes to foreign aid is one of the lowest of all industrial nations, and there are often string attached.  Not to say that we DON'T give aid, we certainly do, just less %age wise, than others do.

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Shaz on 06/18/03 at 10:22 a.m.

Well, our  US government IS us, as a people. So saying they like us but not our government is a contradiction. You can argue all you like but when you boil it down WE are the ones voting these people in to represent us so we ARE our government. I got a really big kick out of the person from France who said they didn't envy us because we are fat. LMAO! I found it interesting that so far if you add it up we are fat, lazy, ignorant, Mcdonalds eating, Jerry Springer watching, war mongering young, stupid individuals with no apparent common sense! HAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA! Thanks for the link to this, I enjoyed it immensely, seeing how I am nothing but an American ignoramus. LOL. Isn't it funny how people see each other from other countries and only see the cliche, instead of the truth of what they really are? And Americans are just as guilty as seeing the cliche in other countries as well...

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: bj26 on 06/18/03 at 10:33 a.m.

Right on, Shaz, I think.

Quoting:
Well, our  US government IS us, as a people. So saying they like us but not our government is a contradiction. You can argue all you like but when you boil it down WE are the ones voting these people in to represent us so we ARE our government. I got a really big kick out of the person from France who said they didn't envy us because we are fat. LMAO! I found it interesting that so far if you add it up we are fat, lazy, ignorant, Mcdonalds eating, Jerry Springer watching, war mongering young, stupid individuals with no apparent common sense! HAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA! Thanks for the link to this, I enjoyed it immensely, seeing how I am nothing but an American ignoramus. LOL. Isn't it funny how people see each other from other countries and only see the cliche, instead of the truth of what they really are? And Americans are just as guilty as seeing the cliche in other countries as well...
End Quote

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: philbo_baggins on 06/18/03 at 10:38 a.m.


Quoting:
Well, our  US government IS us, as a people. So saying they like us but not our government is a contradiction.
End Quote


I surely hope not: I find your government deceitful, aggressive, evasive and incredibly arrogant.  But I've never considered the US people en mass to be so.  In a similar vein, I've disagreed with so much that consecutive governments here have done, I'd hate to be thought of in the same way as any government over the past thirty years.

Phil

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Bobby on 06/18/03 at 11:09 a.m.

I've got to agree with Philbo here.

To tar people with the same brush as a government is like judging sheep by the shepherd (for want of a better analogy).

In my earlier post I never made a judgement as to whether I hated any government. I merely said that humans are human and that is reflected in the actions governments, in general, make.

A 'you're either for us or against us' attitude is not constructive.  :-/



Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Shaz on 06/18/03 at 11:39 a.m.

I see that I need to note my sarcasm, as many things I had said were taken very seriously.

BUT we do elect our officials here, so if something in our government is amiss, we have noone to blame but ourselves. Use your voting power to show the officials how you feel. Rail about the US government all you want, but if you don't vote then you have no right to complain, and if you do vote use it wisely.  ;)

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: John_Harvey on 06/18/03 at 11:45 a.m.

Homer Simpson perfectly embodies America. Even with all our flaws, we eventually get it right... or at least we can get some doughnuts.

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Don_Carlos on 06/18/03 at 12:46 a.m.


Quoting:
Well, our  US government IS us, as a people. So saying they like us but not our government is a contradiction. You can argue all you like but when you boil it down WE are the ones voting these people in to represent us so we ARE our government.
End Quote



On some levels your are obviously correct, but given the disputes we had on this very board over say the Iraqi war, its clear that we all don't approve of our gov't's policies.  The Latin Americans I met never assumed that I supported - or didn't support U.S. policies.  They asked questions to find out, and judged me, as a person, based on my answers.  They didn't make assumptions about me, or associate me with the actions or policies of the Gov't.  That was my point.  I suspect that at any point in time our gov't will be doing something of which you disapprove and would not want to be associated with.  With all respect I hope this clarifies what I was trying to get at.

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: 80s_cheerleader on 06/18/03 at 04:00 p.m.


Quoting:
And by the way Cheerleader, the % or our GNP that goes to foreign aid is one of the lowest of all industrial nations, and there are often string attached.  Not to say that we DON'T give aid, we certainly do, just less %age wise, than others do.
End Quote



This may be true, but, basing it on the total number of dollars we give to other countries, we are currently #1.  So, although %-wise, we are one of the lowest, it is not indicative of the total amount we spend on foreign aid.  

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: dagwood on 06/18/03 at 05:35 p.m.


Quoting:
I agree, Bobby.
It is a shame when a country's citizens are tarnished by the reputation of their leaders..........
End Quote



It is, but it happens everywhere all the time.  Hitler, anyone?  Germans were considered the enemy because of the government...does that mean all of them were bad?  

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: kayhepburn on 06/19/03 at 03:54 a.m.

I agree, Dagwood, that this is the case.  However I do feel that world opinion at present see's America as an extremely patriotic nation.
This is great in one sense as I feel it instills a sense of belonging and pride in the people, which is sadly lacking in some other countries.
However, it can have its downsides too, as the vast majority of American people seem unwilling to criticise their leaders, and they seem to feel that any decison they make must be supported.
I may be wrong here, it is just an obsevation I have picked up from reading various polls and watching British TV.  I feel that this may be affecting the world's opinion of the American populace as a whole.

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: philbo_baggins on 06/19/03 at 03:54 a.m.


Quoting:
Hitler, anyone?  Germans were considered the enemy because of the government...does that mean all of them were bad?  
End Quote


..and he wasn't even German.. but they did start this little war thingie which might prejudice opinion a little bit ;-)

Quote from Tom Lehrer:
Once all the Germans were warlike and mean,
But that couldn't happen again
We taught them a lesson in 1918
And they've hardly bothered us since then

;-)

Phil

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Bobby on 06/19/03 at 06:01 a.m.


Quoting:

..and he wasn't even German.. but they did start this little war thingie which might prejudice opinion a little bit ;-)
End Quote



Hitler was Austrian, I don't think Hitler was his real name either. I heard that his first name was 'Arnold' - Is that right?

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: philbo_baggins on 06/19/03 at 06:29 a.m.

IIRC he was born as "Adolf Schickelgruber", but didn't want to keep his father's name as he didn't know his father, so used his mother's name "Hitler" instead.

...after all, "Heil Schickelgruber" doesn't have quite the same ring to it... they'd never have got the war started that way

Phil
PS Don'cha just love the internet:

Quoting:Adolf's father, Alois Hitler, was the illegitimate son of Maria Anna Schicklgruber. It is generally supposed that the father of Alois Hitler was a Johann Georg Hiedler, a miller's assistant. Alois, however, was not legitimized, and he bore his mother's name until he was forty years of age when he changed it to Hitler.End Quote


Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Bobby on 06/19/03 at 07:04 a.m.


Quoting:
IIRC he was born as "Adolf Schickelgruber", but didn't want to keep his father's name as he didn't know his father, so used his mother's name "Hitler" instead.
End Quote



Why did I think Arnold? I've been watching too much Happy Days on the Paramount Comedy Channel! I knew the last name but I couldn't spell it. LOL!  :D

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Don_Carlos on 06/19/03 at 01:29 p.m.


Quoting:


This may be true, but, basing it on the total number of dollars we give to other countries, we are currently #1.  So, although %-wise, we are one of the lowest, it is not indicative of the total amount we spend on foreign aid.  

End Quote



You are absolutely right, as I tried to suggest.  I guess I would ask, as the richest country in the world, should we not help other poor countries more?  Personally I would say yes, especially in terms of building schools, wells, improving livestock etc. helping people help themselves.  I can understand the other point of view though.

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Goreripper on 06/19/03 at 08:31 p.m.


Quoting:


You are absolutely right, as I tried to suggest.  I guess I would ask, as the richest country in the world, should we not help other poor countries more?  Personally I would say yes, especially in terms of building schools, wells, improving livestock etc. helping people help themselves.  I can understand the other point of view though.
End Quote



I know this is going to sound incredibly cynical and I make no implications from the suggestion other than to voice it but isn't it in the interests of the rich and powerful to keep the poor and weak, poor and weak?

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Screwball54 on 06/19/03 at 09:10 p.m.

Quoting:


I know this is going to sound incredibly cynical and I make no implications from the suggestion other than to voice it but isn't it in the interests of the rich and powerful to keep the poor and weak, poor and weak?
End Quote



That depends on how you look at it.  It is more an issue of dependence.  There is a  certain party of rich people here in the US that want to make the poor dependant on them for their well being, and the more freebees they give out the larger there dependant base.  So whets the big deal you ask?  If they give out all their money won't they be Poor?  Well he is the catch: this group of people doesn't give out their own money.  Instead they give away the income someone else earns, making it harder for someone to attain their level of riches.  That's why I will never vote for a certain political party here in the US...

Subject: Re: Worlds Opinion of America

Written By: Don_Carlos on 06/20/03 at 01:00 p.m.


Quoting:


I know this is going to sound incredibly cynical and I make no implications from the suggestion other than to voice it but isn't it in the interests of the rich and powerful to keep the poor and weak, poor and weak?
End Quote



I don't think so, although I can understand your point.  Poor, weak ENEMIES, yes, but poor, weak friends?  I guess I'd prefer to have strong rich ones.  There is also the question of stability.  The U.S. derives much of its wealth from off-shore investments.  The stability of those countries depends on their prosperity, so the better off they are, the more stable, and therefore the better economic partners they become.