» OLD MESSAGE ARCHIVES «
The Pop Culture Information Society...
Messageboard Archive Index, In The 00s - The Pop Culture Information Society

Welcome to the archived messages from In The 00s. This archive stretches back to 1998 in some instances, and contains a nearly complete record of all the messages posted to inthe00s.com. You will also find an archive of the messages from inthe70s.com, inthe80s.com, inthe90s.com and amiright.com before they were combined to form the inthe00s.com messageboard.

If you are looking for the active messages, please click here. Otherwise, use the links below or on the right hand side of the page to navigate the archives.

Custom Search



Subject: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic?

Written By: ringer on 06/25/03 at 12:45 a.m.

There has been talk about the Islamification of the West.

I hate all religions.  Islam, Christianity, Judiasm.

They have caused only pain and suffering (for the most part).

The left hates Christianity.  Many do anyway.  They don't want it taught in schools.

The right (a good portion) wants Christianity in all facets of life.  They would like the church to have a bigger say in government, the entertainment industry.

They open the sessions of the USA congress with a Christian prayer.

How would they like a Islamic cleric leading one of these?  Do they open with a prayer in any European countries?  I imagine some do.  But I am too lazy to look it up.

Hmmmm.  A lot of folks on the left support a religious Muslim government in the new Iraq.  But a Christian one?  Forget about it.

I head this lady from the paper The Nation advocating this on the TV show meet the press.

Leftists love non-caucasian people.  They have faced discrimination, so they can do no wrong in their minds.  So the fact that non whites make up the majority of Muslims, makes this a great religion.

I disagree.  Anyone seen that nut Islamic type cleric in England with one eye and a hook hand.  Preaching all this anti Western hatred?

He is using Western freedoms to preach this crap.  The brits are maybe gonna throw him out of their country?

Well how about an open border for America and Europe so we can let lots of Muslims in.  And maybe have two big Islamic run continents?

Heh-heh!

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Don_Carlos on 06/25/03 at 02:49 p.m.


Quoting:
There has been talk about the Islamification of the West.

I hate all religions.  Islam, Christianity, Judiasm.

They have caused only pain and suffering (for the most part).

The left hates Christianity.  Many do anyway.  They don't want it taught in schools.

The right (a good portion) wants Christianity in all facets of life.  They would like the church to have a bigger say in government, the entertainment industry.

Hmmmm.  A lot of folks on the left support a religious Muslim government in the new Iraq.  But a Christian one?  Forget about it.

I head this lady from the paper The Nation advocating this on the TV show meet the press.

Leftists love non-caucasian people.  They have faced discrimination, so they can do no wrong in their minds.  So the fact that non whites make up the majority of Muslims, makes this a great religion.

I disagree.  Anyone seen that nut Islamic type cleric in England with one eye and a hook hand.  Preaching all this anti Western hatred?

He is using Western freedoms to preach this crap.  The brits are maybe gonna throw him out of their country?

Well how about an open border for America and Europe so we can let lots of Muslims in.  And maybe have two big Islamic run continents?

Heh-heh!
End Quote



I will regfrain from expressing my first reaction to this post - it would be much too inflantory.  But I will respond to it rationally and factually point by point.

Part 1

1. "I hate all religions..."
It is certtainly true that religious intolerance has spawned hatred and violence - and it still does.  But the source is not the religions themselves, since virtuall all preach love and acceptance, but the intolerance of the believers towards non-believers.  In many cases, if one digs deep enough, one finds that socio-economic motivations are being masked by religious zeal.

"The left hates Christianity..."
First off, I'm not sure what "the left" means.  There are so many variations on Left - radical - socialist - Marxist - Maoist - Leninist - .... that to characterize "the left" as a monolith is as bad as charaterizing all those who claim to be "conservative" as being of one mind.
Second, the statement is simply wrong.  To begin, many "leftist" that I know are also sincere Christians who believe that socialism, in one form or another, comes closest to fulfilling Christ's message as they understand it.  The other "leftist" I know don't hate any group as a whole.  Me and my leftist friends are very selective with who we "hate" and try to keep that to a mininum.  
As to not wanting Christianity "taught in the schools", its not only leftists that have a problem with that.  The first amendment gaurantees freedom of - or from - religion.  That means that our public schools, financed by taxes payed by members of ALL religions, should not promote ANY religion.  Private schools SHOULD be able - are - to teach religion as they see fit.

"The right want Christianity..."
There certainly are a group of self proclaimed right wind Christian fundamentalists who believe that the U.S. is a "Christian" country and that they are the ONLY Christians.  Based on the Christians that I know, they are a minority.

Leftist support an Islamic gov't in Iraq:
None that I know of!  In fact, one reason that I OPPOSED the Iraqi war was that whilr it would overthrow a brutal, sadistic, secular gov't, it would, if we allowed "democracy" - the will of the people - to take its course, we would wind up with a fundamentalist Islamic state resembling the Taliban.  And from what I read, the handwriting is on the wall.  How could it be consistant for leftist to oppose the "theocratization" of U.S. gov't and support the development of theocracy in Iraq?  No leftist that I know, or have read, does so, although many, my self included, predicted that outcome.  Prediction is NOT advocacy.

"Leftist love non-caucasion people..."
This defies comment, but some history.  Estimates are that some 3.5 +million Africans who had been "exported" from that continent  reached the Americas, probably about 75% of those loaded in Africa.  Estimates are that the native population of the Americas was +/- 80,000,000 in 1492.  By 1700 that figure was down to +/- 2,000,000.  I have no figures on the population impact of European expansion into Asia.  The leftist that I know understand the histoeical legacy of conquest and imperialism, and TEND to support indiginoius peoples in their struggles for recognition and equality.  

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Don_Carlos on 06/25/03 at 02:57 p.m.


Quoting:
 Anyone seen that nut Islamic type cleric in England with one eye and a hook hand.  Preaching all this anti Western hatred?

He is using Western freedoms to preach this crap.  The brits are maybe gonna throw him out of their country?

End Quote



And in the late 1920's and early '30s there were religioious leaders like Father Coughlin, who advocated fasism for this country, and were protected by the 1st amendment.  While I don't agree with this, or any other religious fanatic, if freedom of speech does not imply the right to freely express that which is unpopular than what does it protect, the right to agree?  On the contrary.  Freedom of speach is the right to freely say, without retribution, that which is UNPOPULAR.  If not that, then it is meaningless.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: ringer on 06/25/03 at 04:54 p.m.

Don Carlos, let me guess, you're a Marxist?

Please don't tell me you like Fidel.  Or the bearded one as he is know in some circles outside of Cuba.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: dagwood on 06/25/03 at 05:18 p.m.


Quoting:


I will regfrain from expressing my first reaction to this post - it would be much too inflantory.
End Quote



Wow, Don Carlos, you have hit the nail on the head here.  
 

Quoting:
As to not wanting Christianity "taught in the schools", its not only leftists that have a problem with that.  The first amendment gaurantees freedom of - or from - religion.  That means that our public schools, financed by taxes payed by members of ALL religions, should not promote ANY religion.  Private schools SHOULD be able - are - to teach religion as they see fit.
End Quote



This is so true.  I am a Born Again Christian, a Republican and consider myself part of the right.  I understand that Ringer said most of the right not all.  I don't want religion taught in public schools.  It isn't right.  Not everyone has the same belief system and it isn't fair to those children.  If you want your children to learn religion in school, private school would be the answer.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: ringer on 06/25/03 at 05:46 p.m.

We need more Republicans like you.

Glad there are execeptions to the rule.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Bobby on 06/25/03 at 06:21 p.m.

I'll stay out of this one - I know when I'm 'in too deep' (Copright - Phil Collins)

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: My_name_is_Kenny on 06/25/03 at 06:56 p.m.

Ow.  My head.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Goreripper on 06/25/03 at 08:10 p.m.

I'm really not sure what the point of this thread is, but part of it seemed to suggest some kind of religious government in Iraq? For all its faults, a significant aspect of the previous government was its secular leanings; I think a secular government would be very important in a nation such as Iraq, one where there is an official religion, but where other religions are free to be practised. This would be an important step in stabilising the country. As for the Islamification of the West, one of the ultimate goals of Islam is for it to be the one true global religion; even until quite recently, Christianity had the same idea, but the Islamification of the predominantly Christian West is as about as likely as the Christianisation of the Middle East, especially when they remain so hostile to each other.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: John_Harvey on 06/25/03 at 09:18 p.m.

Leftists hate Christianity? Perhaps I should go talk to Father Shuda about this. Ever hear of the religious left? Ever hear of the Catholic Workers' movement? I love Jesus as much as the next guy, but I don't go forcing him onto the people we just blew up. As far as an Islamic government goes in Iraq, it's should be up to them which government they have. If it goes religious, so be it. It's their country.

Okay, back to Christianity and Leftism.

As I have said before, the Catholic Church has provided us with the only successful Communistic societies in the history of mankind. Monestaries and early Christian communities are about as red as they come.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: XenaKat13 on 06/25/03 at 09:58 p.m.

Like Don Carlos, I am not going to post my first reaction.


And I agree with Dagwood.  Religion should not be taught in free public schools.  What if the school teaches Hinduism?  Would Christian parents want their children to go there?  Most likely not.....but since all children MUST go to school, they wouldn't really have a choice.  


As to whether the West "should" become Islamic or not....


Keep in mind that there are many, many different "sects" of Islam, just as there are many, many different sects of Christianity and Judaism.


Not all Muslims preach or believe in hate, violence and subjugation of women.  It just seems that way because they are the only ones who are getting any TV coverage these days.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Dude on 06/26/03 at 02:09 a.m.

I can't believe that y'all are giving this idiotic rhetoric the justification that you are by even responding to it.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: ringer on 06/26/03 at 10:20 a.m.

I can believe it.

LOL.

It deserves discussion.  Even though I was doing stream of conciousness writing...

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Don_Carlos on 06/29/03 at 01:56 p.m.

Let me clarify my views on "teaching religion".  I would have no objection to a high school course on Major World Religions if it were taught by someone who was qualified to teach it, and it did not ADVOCATE for any particular one.  I think there  is a difference between "teaching a religion" and teraching ABOUT religion.  I think it would be fine for students to read excerpts from the Bible (several versions), the Koran, the Rig Veta of Hinduism, etc. but public schools should not advocate for any religion.

I'm not anti-religion, just anti-sectarian.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Anthony716 on 07/02/03 at 11:50 a.m.

I think St. Dominic once said: "Put them all to the sword and God will know his own"

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: John_Seminal on 07/02/03 at 01:31 p.m.

Quoting:

I will regfrain from expressing my first reaction to this post - it would be much too inflantory.  But I will respond to it rationally and factually point by point.
End Quote



I won't refrain  ;D . This guy Ringer is an  who is afraid to use his real identity  >:( . Where did he come up with crap like "the left hates christians and loves all non-whites"?? This guy must have been brainwashed by idiots like O'Rielly and Limbaugh and Liddy. We need more mainstream reporting.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Don_Carlos on 07/02/03 at 02:04 p.m.

Quoting:


I won't refrain  ;D . This guy Ringer is an  who is afraid to use his real identity  >:( . Where did he come up with crap like "the left hates christians and loves all non-whites"?? This guy must have been brainwashed by idiots like O'Rielly and Limbaugh and Liddy. We need more mainstream reporting.
End Quote



I agree that we need better journalism, although I question "mainstream".  We need an active, independent, investigative journalistic community that is not controlled by a few media giants.  My guess is that this is more like what you meant.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Davester on 07/11/03 at 00:52 a.m.

  The problem is not Islam itself, nor Islamic societies, but that God sets different priorities for Muslims.

  If we want to talk about dysfunctional societies, let's take a look at Christianity. If we want to stay modern, as some seem to want to, all the better because American "Christians" (Bush included) are a perfect example of the dysfunctional state of Western society.

  Justice, as interpreted by Muslims, is a huge factor. In Islam, Justice is very, very important. In Christianity, it is not so important because God will avenge the suffering. This is why Christians are told to "turn the other cheek" when someone strikes them. Yet you'll notice that most Americans would rather be Muslims in one sense: when offended, Muslims are told to strike back until aggression ceases. I find it odd that Westerners pick on the Islamic call to fight for justice, since most Americans prefer that method despite specific instructions otherwise in the Bible.

  It's merely a matter of priorities. In the United States, if something is amiss, people will say, "It costs too much to worry about it."

  In Islam, regardless of how one interprets justice, Justice does not play second fiddle to profit.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: John_Seminal on 07/11/03 at 09:24 a.m.


Quoting:
In Islam, regardless of how one interprets justice, Justice does not play second fiddle to profit.
End Quote



Really??

From what I saw on TV, those oil shiek families seem to be awfully wealthy and free, while the muslim on the streets has to cover her head or be punished.

They showed one of the royal families in Saudi Arabia, and their palace was the size of a small city, complete with a movie theater where they watched american movies. Amazing how money equals freedom even for an islamic nation.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: CatwomanofV on 07/11/03 at 09:34 a.m.


Quoting:


Really??

From what I saw on TV, those oil shiek families seem to be awfully wealthy and free, while the muslim on the streets has to cover her head or be punished.

They showed one of the royal families in Saudi Arabia, and their palace was the size of a small city, complete with a movie theater where they watched american movies. Amazing how money equals freedom even for an islamic nation.
End Quote




Unfortunately, this falls under the "Golden Rule" (which is the same in the U.S.) "He with the gold, makes the rules." It has been that way since the beginning of time.


Cat

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Hoeveel on 07/11/03 at 10:23 a.m.


Quoting:
There has been talk about the Islamification of the West.

I hate all religions.  Islam, Christianity, Judiasm.

They have caused only pain and suffering (for the most part).

The left hates Christianity.  Many do anyway.  They don't want it taught in schools.

The right (a good portion) wants Christianity in all facets of life.  They would like the church to have a bigger say in government, the entertainment industry.

They open the sessions of the USA congress with a Christian prayer.

How would they like a Islamic cleric leading one of these?  Do they open with a prayer in any European countries?  I imagine some do.  But I am too lazy to look it up.

Hmmmm.  A lot of folks on the left support a religious Muslim government in the new Iraq.  But a Christian one?  Forget about it.

I head this lady from the paper The Nation advocating this on the TV show meet the press.

Leftists love non-caucasian people.  They have faced discrimination, so they can do no wrong in their minds.  So the fact that non whites make up the majority of Muslims, makes this a great religion.

I disagree.  Anyone seen that nut Islamic type cleric in England with one eye and a hook hand.  Preaching all this anti Western hatred?

He is using Western freedoms to preach this crap.  The brits are maybe gonna throw him out of their country?

Well how about an open border for America and Europe so we can let lots of Muslims in.  And maybe have two big Islamic run continents?

Heh-heh!
End Quote



Are you talking about Britain becoming a country under Sharia law? That would rock!

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Hoeveel on 07/11/03 at 10:43 a.m.


Quoting:
Islamification of the predominantly Christian West is as about as likely as the Christianisation of the Middle East, especially when they remain so hostile to each other.
End Quote



I disagree, isn't Islam the fastest growing religion in the world? And as ringer says 'they can do no wrong' so why not join them? It's never been more trendy to be a muslim, ya know.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Hoeveel on 07/11/03 at 10:53 a.m.

Quoting:


I won't refrain  ;D . This guy Ringer is an  who is afraid to use his real identity  >:( . Where did he come up with crap like "the left hates christians and loves all non-whites"?? This guy must have been brainwashed by idiots like O'Rielly and Limbaugh and Liddy. We need more mainstream reporting.
End Quote



I dunno. To be fair, one of my pet-peeves about the left is that they are far too PC.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Hoeveel on 07/11/03 at 10:56 a.m.


Quoting:


Really??

From what I saw on TV, those oil shiek families seem to be awfully wealthy and free, while the muslim on the streets has to cover her head or be punished.

End Quote



Erm...don't they have to cover their heads in the oil sheikh families too?

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: DizzleJ on 07/11/03 at 07:50 p.m.


Quoting:


I disagree, isn't Islam the fastest growing religion in the world? And as ringer says 'they can do no wrong' so why not join them? It's never been more trendy to be a muslim, ya know.
End Quote



Actually I believe That The Church Of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints is the fastest growing sect of Christianity, faster than Islam!
Also, there are many things wrong with "Muslims".
Islam is a religion that teaches similar things as Christianity.
However many modern day Muslims have thier own interpetations of the Koram (whatever thier "Bible").
Just like every Christian sect, interpets the same Bible differently. Just like Chrisianity used to be a pure religion, till the "Catholics" started coming up with thier own rules, just so they could get money. The original Christian Church pretty much died with the Apostles. Thus, the Dark ages, absence of any true/divine doctrine.
Anyway my point is hardly any of the modern day Muslims are of the same mindset as Mohammed and his early followers.
That is why many feel killing infedels or Christians or Americans is "Justified" by God. While the God Mohammed preached of would never agree with any killing.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Hoeveel on 07/11/03 at 08:41 p.m.

Quoting:


Also, there are many things wrong with "Muslims".

...many feel killing infedels or Christians or Americans is "Justified" by God.
End Quote



You've only mentioned one thing there.

Quoting:

Just like Chrisianity used to be a pure religion, till the "Catholics" started coming up with thier own rules, just so they could get money.

End Quote



Not to mention the whimsical creation of Protestantism by Henry VIII. And you could make a passing nod to the Latter Day Saints here too.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: zippo on 07/11/03 at 11:12 p.m.

Islam is a violent religion.

It is NOT a good thing.

Religion period is not a good thing.

Get rid of it.  The world will be mch better!

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Hoeveel on 07/12/03 at 06:40 a.m.


Quoting:
Islam is a violent religion.

End Quote



You going to back that up with something?

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: John_Seminal on 07/12/03 at 09:44 a.m.

Quoting:


You going to back that up with something?
End Quote



Like a J'ihad?

Modified to add: That is a joke :D

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Hoeveel on 07/12/03 at 09:49 a.m.

Yup. Heheh. Got that.

Well...Admittedly, it was after reading the rest of the words. My initial reaction to seeing the word Jihad was much different  :D ;)

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Davester on 07/12/03 at 10:46 a.m.


Quoting:


Really??

From what I saw on TV, those oil shiek families seem to be awfully wealthy and free, while the muslim on the streets has to cover her head or be punished.

They showed one of the royal families in Saudi Arabia, and their palace was the size of a small city, complete with a movie theater where they watched american movies. Amazing how money equals freedom even for an islamic nation.
End Quote



  Sorta beside the point, dontcha think? ;)

  In general, it's not that Islam is above reproach, but that the people criticizing it the loudest don't seem to have much of a clue.

  Some people around here should learn about what they fear. A rational fear is easily managed; an irrational fear can possess a person.

  Look, I'm hardly an expert on Islam, but I do know that the reading I do on religions and similar social phenomena, as with politics, transcends common issues.

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Hairspray on 07/13/03 at 09:11 p.m.

Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic?

Absolutely Not.

Why?

I think Confusianism sounds much better! :D

Subject: Re: Europe and America: Should They Become Islamic

Written By: Goreripper on 07/13/03 at 09:25 p.m.


Quoting:


Really??

From what I saw on TV, those oil shiek families seem to be awfully wealthy and free, while the muslim on the streets has to cover her head or be punished.

End Quote



This is not quite correct. It is only in certain sects of Islam that the female head covering (I believe it is called the burkha) is compulsory. In the more secular areas of the Muslim world, it's up to the individual as to whether to wear it, or not. Under the Taliban for example, the women couldn't even leave the house without a male family member. In Iraq and Egypt, where a more moderate form of Islam is practised, the rules are somewhat more liberal. Many of the wealthier sheikhs are liberal to the point of being completely secular.