inthe00s
The Pop Culture Information Society...

These are the messages that have been posted on inthe00s over the past few years.

Check out the messageboard archive index for a complete list of topic areas.

This archive is periodically refreshed with the latest messages from the current messageboard.




Check for new replies or respond here...

Subject: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: Philip Eno on 11/30/17 at 5:58 am

Disney has picked Chinese actor Liu Yifei to play Mulan in an upcoming film, following accusations against Hollywood of 'whitewashing'. The live-action adaptation of the 1998 animated movie will tell the tale of the famed Chinese heroine Hua Mulan. Several Hollywood films have faced criticism in recent months for featuring white actors in Asian roles. Thousands took part in an online campaign calling for an Asian actress to be cast as Mulan. Recent films accused of whitewashing include the Hollywood remake of Japanese anime Ghost in the Shell, which had Scarlett Johansson in the main role which was originally Japanese, and Chinese epic The Great Wall which starred Matt Damon as its lead character.

https://ichef-1.bbci.co.uk/news/660/cpsprodpb/086F/production/_98995120_gettyimages-539427894.jpg

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-china-42177082

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: ofkx on 12/01/17 at 7:55 am

That’s awesome :D. I’m so happy that Disney isn’t doing the White savior/whitewashing thing a lot of movies do. It’s quite refreshing tbh  ;D

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: 80sfan on 12/01/17 at 8:39 am

It's so arrogant to cast some other race to play the original character. Yeah, I said it, arrogant. Glad they made the character Chinese.

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: 2001 on 12/01/17 at 10:53 am

She looks majestic!  8)

Glad she got the role. Glad Asians are breaking into Hollywood in roles that aren't nerd, convenience store owner or martial artist.  ::)

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: ZeldaFan20 on 12/01/17 at 5:19 pm

Massive props for Disney 8)!

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: TheReignMan99 on 12/01/17 at 5:27 pm


It's so arrogant to cast some other race to play the original character. Yeah, I said it, arrogant. Glad they made the character Chinese.

The word you're looking for is ignorant not arrogant.

Just helping you out :P.

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: TheReignMan99 on 12/01/17 at 5:31 pm


She looks majestic!  8)

100% AGREED! 8)


Glad she got the role. Glad Asians are breaking into Hollywood in roles that aren't nerd, convenience store owner or martial artist.  ::)

Well, technically, Mulan is a bit of a stereotypical role.

There needs to be more Asian characters that don't have much or any basis in an ancient Asian country or ritual. Have Asian people in normal roles like Fresh Off the Boat....because Asian people are like every one else. Not every Asian person is an ancient warrior or princess ;D.

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: 80sfan on 12/01/17 at 5:42 pm


The word you're looking for is ignorant not arrogant.

Just helping you out :P.


Both.

It's kinda uppity. Imagine there were people (grey race/people) who wouldn't cast a purple skinned person (made up race), but will cast their own race, yet will presume and assume that the purple person won't make enough money because of the person's skin color/race, yet won't even give the purple person/people a chance.

That's an assumption and it's kind of um, uppity. Arrogant is too strong of a world.

I don't think all, or even most, white people, are this way. I'm just talking about the white people in Hollywood, especially those with so much power.

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: TheReignMan99 on 12/01/17 at 6:52 pm


Both.

It's kinda uppity. Imagine there were people (grey race/people) who wouldn't cast a purple skinned person (made up race), but will cast their own race, yet will presume and assume that the purple person won't make enough money because of the person's skin color/race, yet won't even give the purple person/people a chance.

That's an assumption and it's kind of um, uppity. Arrogant is too strong of a world.

I don't think all, or even most, white people, are this way. I'm just talking about the white people in Hollywood, especially those with so much power.

Nah, it's ignorance because of the fact that they willing know that they could give an Asian person the role but instead give it to a person not from an Asian background. It's also ignorance because of the fact that many Hollywood producers use the "We didn't want to cast unknowns to do the parts" excuse.

Arrogance would be if they thought that no Asian person at all could do the role as well as a non-Asian person.

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: ofkx on 12/02/17 at 4:34 am


Nah, it's ignorance because of the fact that they willing know that they could give an Asian person the role but instead give it to a person not from an Asian background. It's also ignorance because of the fact that many Hollywood producers use the "We didn't want to cast unknowns to do the parts" excuse.

Arrogance would be if they thought that no Asian person at all could do the role as well as a non-Asian person.

I'm pretty sure that's one of the main reasons they cast white people in roles meant for POC.

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: TheReignMan99 on 12/02/17 at 5:04 am


I'm pretty sure that's one of the main reasons they cast white people in roles meant for POC.

No, that's not true. They know that they are Asian actors who can do the roles just as well but they purposefully choose not to cast an Asian actor...that is plain ignorance NOT arrogance.

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: ofkx on 12/02/17 at 5:36 am


No, that's not true. They know that they are Asian actors who can do the roles just as well but they purposefully choose not to cast an Asian actor...that is plain ignorance NOT arrogance.

This is a pretty silly discussion, don't you think? ;D

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: TheReignMan99 on 12/02/17 at 6:36 am


This is a pretty silly discussion, don't you think? ;D

No. Ignorance and arrogance aren't the same thing. Yes, sometimes they can interlap but Whitewashing in Hollywood is mostly due to ignorance NOT arrogrance. Asian actors are being IGNORed....thus it's IGNORance...get it? :)

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: ofkx on 12/02/17 at 7:38 am


No. Ignorance and arrogance aren't the same thing. Yes, sometimes they can interlap but Whitewashing in Hollywood is mostly due to ignorance NOT arrogrance. Asian actors are being IGNORed....thus it's IGNORance...get it? :)

It's both.
It's arrogance because they think that they (white people) are better than others, so they cast a white person instead of a POC. It's also ignorance because they aren't aware that there are POC that can portray the characters amazingly...get it? :)

Subject: Re: Disney casts Chinese actress Liu Yifei in Mulan lead role

Written By: TheReignMan99 on 12/02/17 at 12:32 pm


It's both.
It's arrogance because they think that they (white people) are better than others, so they cast a white person instead of a POC. It's also ignorance because they aren't aware that there are POC that can portray the characters amazingly...get it? :)

No, that is false but if you feel that is how it is then....whatever. Whitewashing is obviously about being ignorant towards others NOT arrogant.

However, as Burger King says "Have it your way".

Check for new replies or respond here...