Wild Horses  --1
Sympathy For The Devil  --2
Fool To Cry  --1
Angie  --1
It's Only Rock And Roll  --1
Happy  --2
Beast Of Burden  --1
Don't Stop --? (don't recall right now)
Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie)  --1
Get Off Of My Cloud  --2
Paint It Black  --3
You Can't Always Get What You Want  --3
I Can't Get No Satisfaction  --2
Miss You  --2
Street Fighting Man  --3
Jumping Jack Flash  --3
Honky Tonk Woman  --2
Shattered  --3
Start Me Up  --4
Waiting On A Friend  --1
Gimme Shelter  --2
Tumbling Dice  --5
Like A Rolling Stone (Bob Dylan Cover)  --? (don't recall this one right now)
Ruby Tuesday  --1
Under My Thumb  --1
Brown Sugar  --1


And the winners are

You Can't Always Get What You Want  --3
Street Fighting Man  --3
Jumping Jack Flash  --3
Shattered  --3
Start Me Up  --3.5 (Their last good song)
Tumbling Dice  --5 (Yes, it's my favorite by them)

And don't forget

She's a Rainbow  --4

Wild Horses  d/k
Sympathy For The Devil  d/k
Fool To Cry  d/k
Angie  3
It's Only Rock And Roll  d/k
Happy  d/k
Beast Of Burden  a.k.a. "Pizza Burnin'"...4
Don't Stop  d/k
Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie)  haven't heard that rendition yet
Get Off Of My Clown Cloud  4
Paint It Black  d/k
You Can't Always Get What You Want  2
I Can't Get No Satisfaction  4
Miss You  d/k
Street Fighting Man  d/k
Jumping Jack Flash  4
Honky Tonk Woman  d/k
Shattered  d/k
Start Me Up  5
Waiting On A Friend  d/k
Gimme Shelter  d/k
Tumbling Dice  d/k
Like A Rolling Stone (Bob Dylan Cover)
Ruby Tuesday  d/k
Under My Thumb  d/k
Brown Sugar  1

write ins:
Time Is On My Side  4

Wild Horses  2
Sympathy For The Devil  2
Fool To Cry  D/K
Angie  3
It's Only Rock And Roll  2.5
Happy  D/K
Beast Of Burden  2
Don't Stop  D/K
Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie)  3.5
Get Off Of My Cloud  2
Paint, It Black  2 
You Can't Always Get What You Want  2
I Can't Get No Satisfaction  3
Miss You  3.5
Street Fighting Man  D/K
Jumping Jack Flash  3
Honky Tonk Woman  5  ...and the only song of theirs that I really like
Shattered  D/K
Start Me Up  3
Waiting On A Friend  3
Gimme Shelter  D/K
Tumbling Dice  3
Like A Rolling Stone (Bob Dylan Cover)  2
Ruby Tuesday  3
Under My Thumb  2.5
Brown Sugar  3

Wild Horses - 3
Sympathy For The Devil - 4
Fool To Cry - 2
Angie - 3
It's Only Rock And Roll - 2
Happy - ?
Beast Of Burden - 3
Don't Stop - ?
Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie) - 1 (some things are better left untouched...charity or not)
Get Off Of My Cloud - 4
Paint It Black - 5
You Can't Always Get What You Want - 4
I Can't Get No Satisfaction - 5
Miss You - 2
Street Fighting Man - 4
Jumping Jack Flash - 4
Honky Tonk Woman - 4
Shattered - ?
Start Me Up - 5 (from the early 70s onwards, the Stones gradually slid toward the pit marked 'mediocrity'...this was an honourable exception...)
Waiting On A Friend - 4 (see above)
Gimme Shelter - 3
Tumbling Dice - 3
Like A Rolling Stone (Bob Dylan Cover) - ?
Ruby Tuesday - 5
Under My Thumb - 4
Brown Sugar - 5

And two of my favourites that weren't listed here...
Mother's Little Helper
She's A Rainbow

1=Bad 5=Good 666=Number of the Beast

Wild Horses  ?
Sympathy For The Devil  ?
Fool To Cry - 5
Angie     5
It's Only Rock And Roll    5
Happy ?
Beast Of Burden 1
Don't Stop 5
Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie) ?
Get Off Of My Cloud  5
Paint It Black  1
You Can't Always Get What You Want  1
I Can't Get No Satisfaction  5
Miss You   5
Street Fighting Man  ?
Jumping Jack Flash   5
Honky Tonk Woman   5
Shattered  1
Start Me Up   5
Waiting On A Friend   5
Gimme Shelter   1
Tumbling Dice   1
Like A Rolling Stone (Bob Dylan Cover)  ?
Ruby Tuesday  1
Under My Thumb   1
Brown Sugar  5

Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie) - 4
Paint It Black - 3
You Can't Always Get What You Want - 3
I Can't Get No Satisfaction - 5
Start Me Up - 4
Brown Sugar - 3

Might I also add:
Love Is Strong(1994) - 4

I haven't paid much attention to the Stones, but it's cool that they lasted so long.

1=Bad 5=Good 666=Number of the Beast

Wild Horses
Sympathy For The Devil
Fool To Cry
Angie
It's Only Rock And Roll
Happy
Beast Of Burden
Don't Stop
Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie)
Get Off Of My Cloud
Paint It Black
You Can't Always Get What You Want
I Can't Get No Satisfaction
Miss You
Street Fighting Man
Jumping Jack Flash
Honky Tonk Woman
Shattered
Start Me Up
Waiting On A Friend
Gimme Shelter
Tumbling Dice
Like A Rolling Stone (Bob Dylan Cover)
Ruby Tuesday
Under My Thumb

Brown Sugar

they all get a 10

Wild Horses 4
Sympathy For The Devil 4
Fool To Cry 3
Angie 4
It's Only Rock And Roll 5
Happy 3
Beast Of Burden 2
Don't Stop 4
Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie) 3
Get Off Of My Cloud 4
Paint It Black 2
You Can't Always Get What You Want 5
I Can't Get No Satisfaction 4
Miss You 3
Street Fighting Man 2
Jumping Jack Flash 4
Honky Tonk Woman 4
Shattered 2
Start Me Up 4
Waiting On A Friend 2
Gimme Shelter 5
Tumbling Dice 2
Like A Rolling Stone (Bob Dylan Cover) 4
Ruby Tuesday 5
Under My Thumb 4

DK='s Don't Know, but I bet I would if I heard it

Wild Horses-DK
Sympathy For The Devi-DK
Fool To Cry-DK
Angie-2
It's Only Rock And Roll-DK, but probably do & would give it a 3 or 4
Happy-DK
Beast Of Burden-5
Don't Stop-DK
Dancing In The Street (Solo w/ David Bowie)-3
Get Off Of My Cloud-2
Paint It Black-4
You Can't Always Get What You Want-2
I Can't Get No Satisfaction-1
Miss You-3
Street Fighting Man-DK
Jumping Jack Flash-2
Honky Tonk Woman-3
Shattered-DK
Start Me Up-5
Waiting On A Friend-3
Gimme Shelter-DK
Tumbling Dice-DK
Like A Rolling Stone (Bob Dylan Cover)-3
Ruby Tuesday-1
Under My Thumb-1

Brown Sugar-1